Having seen the social media for the re-opening and soft launch of this venue in Derbyshire occurring just before our visit to the area, I was quite excited. We booked Sunday Lunch before we arrived in Ashford in the Water, and I was hopeful to book some evening meals too.
Sunday Lunch food quality wise was excellent. Although temperature wise, it had a little of the three bears story about it, the mash was too cool, almost cold, the cauliflower cheese was at the other extreme, much hotter than the main items of the main dish, which was just right.
Drink wise, asking for ‘hot water’ when we arrived sent the staff into a little bit of a spin ….. after my third request and a long wait, from my initial request. I’ll always wonder, was the overheard discussion of several staff in the corner behind me, ‘its not something we offer, its not on the computer’ related to the hot water?
Sadly there was fluff floating about in the bottom half of the water in the cup, so it was fluff and hot water.
This though, wasn’t the first niggle of the experience. We arrived, made eye contact with someone at the bar who then disappeared, returned, didn’t make eye contact and disappeared again. The energy given off very much unwelcome. After a wait they returned again and said ‘reception is out the back’ before darting back behind the bar again. Going out back I just found another bar and similar experience.
It seemed we’d come in the wrong door. Once seated, having to retrace our steps to the front bar again, service to establish our drink and food order was very very quick. There wasn’t really time to land, get one’s coat off and look at the menu.
Sadly, for Scientist, the initial poor start had left him almost ready to leave before we’d ordered the food. A most unusual occurrence and he felt he didn’t wish to return for an evening meal, even though we both agreed the food was good. And the beer, very good.
I though, determined to see if it was possible, asked about availability later in the week. I’d work on the good things, like the good beer, food and the sport of seeing how long hot water would take next time in order to persuade him.
‘We’re very busy’ was the abrupt response which made me wonder if in fact they’d rather we didn’t enquire any further.
Speedily spoken, ‘if you know when you want a table, I’ll see if anything is available for that day and time’, was the follow up. A perhaps, helpful answer, although tone wise it didn’t feel it – I felt more of a hinderance. I said I’ll look online.
Once back at our accommodation again, I found all time slots were available all week. ‘Hmm, not that busy’ said Scientist, ‘beer was good, food was good, but I don’t think they’ve got their service quite right yet, I’d rather give it a complete miss’.
And so that was its fate sealed for our week in Ashford in the Water this time. even though the beer and food were good.

