The Cleave, Lustleigh

Jan 12, 2025 | British Isles Tour, Feasting

Venison Burger dressed salad, coleslaw and skin on fries
Glass ramekin of pale vanilla creme brulee under a toffee coloured surface, adored with half a strawberry, raspberry and kumquat. A small circular shortbread biscuit beside it on a white plate.
White, thatched building, village pub in Lustleigh, Devon.

Under new management and only open a few weeks, we were pleased that the Cleave in Lustleigh, Devon was open and offering food for our visit.

We originally booked a table for one night, and we were pleased with what we found so we booked a second night once we were there.

Dan, one of the new guardians was friendly, had a great personality and was keen to please.    The beer was great and there was a good wine offering.  Spirits were a little on the limited side, due to the time in residence – no single malt whisky and limited rum offerings.

The food menu changed a little between the two visits – this may have been due to the second visit being on the busy night of the Wassail celebrations and a packed pub.   And the food continuity from our first visit and second was variable – perhaps related to different chefs.  The venison burger the first night being rare and the second much more juicy and more well-cooked.  My preference was actually for the second night’s offering.   And on the first visit the fries were well salted whilst on the second (and to my preference) they were only lightly seasoned. Sadly the sweet potato burger didn’t hit the mark for me, (but I know I’m not particularly keen on sweet potato), I was intrigued and had hoped the walnut and avocado would create a magical combination.

Generally, the food was decent, the wine and beer good.   Accompanying salad, wonderful, well dressed and tasted crisp and fresh.  A real gift compared to many pubs’ limp leaves and colourless tomato.  Price wise, I believe locals have experienced a hike in prices with the change in management, but pricing was in line with what we’d expect to pay in a pub based on our recent travels.

Service was slower than we’re used to.  But perhaps that is also a gift, if you’ve booked a table its so nice not to be on the 2-hour-and-your-time-at-the-table-is-up roller-coaster that seems to be becoming the norm in many places offering food.  The other lovely thing was the space between tables.  Diners were not squeezed in.

I had hoped to see a list of local produce suppliers on the menu – but being new, building up this sort of knowledge takes time.

We enjoyed our meal and drinks there and would visit again. 

I do hope though that they quickly sort out the under-charging bill issues.  It can be frustrating (as well as costly to a business).  On the first night our bill was one round of drinks light.  On the second two rounds light.   We were honest and asked for the missing items to be added.    Hopefully this too is a teething issue and doesn’t cost them dearly.   A village with a pub is such an asset and blessing.

Leaves with red peppers, red onion, scoop of chicken liver parfait and a piece of white lightly toast bread.
Fried sweet potato cake on lettuce inside bread bun. Salad, coleslaw, pot of beetroot & cumin ketchup and fries.
A slice of Gamekeeper Pie, broccoli and colcannon mash with gravy.

Tags: